The (Not So) Subtle Art of Overthinking at Work

There is a particular kind of email that takes three minutes to write and fifteen minutes to send. Usually, it is something straightforward: a follow-up, a small request or an update. Yet there I am, wondering whether “just checking” sounds hesitant, “following up” sounds impatient and the exclamation mark suggests more enthusiasm than the situation demands. The person receiving it probably wants the attachment. I am still deciding how warmly to introduce it.

As a writer, I can defend some of this attention. Choosing words carefully is part of my work. What becomes harder to defend is spending ten minutes choosing between two sentences that communicate exactly the same thing. At some point, I have to ask whether I am improving the message or trying to guarantee a response I cannot control.

The meeting before the meeting

Overthinking has a way of making itself look useful. You are considering possibilities, checking assumptions and anticipating questions. All sensible things to do, until you have conducted an entire discussion in your head without contributing to the one happening around you.

Perhaps you have an idea but want to explain it properly. While you are checking whether it is relevant, original or sufficiently developed, the conversation moves on. Someone else suggests something similar, and you nod with the slightly complicated satisfaction of having thought of it too.

I understand the wish to make a thought presentable before sharing it. But colleagues can help develop an idea only once they have heard it. Holding back until I can answer every possible objection means losing the benefit of their thinking while getting thoroughly exhausted by my own.

The revision that nobody asked for

Writing gives this habit plenty of respectable hiding places. A draft can almost always be adjusted, which makes “I’m still working on it” a convincing explanation long after the necessary work is done.

The distinction becomes clearer when I ask what the next change will achieve. If the opening takes too long, I can shorten it. If the meaning is unclear, I can untangle the sentence. But if I am replacing “begin” with “start” and then restoring “begin”, I may need to close the document.

One habit I find particularly revealing is changing a line without reading what comes before and after it. The replacement sounds better in isolation, so I put it in. Then the paragraph feels wrong, and another round begins. Sometimes the original sentence was doing its job perfectly well; I had simply grown tired of looking at it.

The time spent reconsidering a finished task also comes from somewhere. It can leave me rushing through the next piece of work, even when that needs my attention more.

When the work leaves and the worry stays

Submitting the work should settle things, at least temporarily. Instead, it can free up the mind to remember every alternative it rejected earlier.

A different opening suddenly seems stronger. A comment made during a meeting sounds awkward in retrospect. While waiting for feedback, it becomes tempting to treat a delayed reply as evidence that something is wrong.

The difficulty is that these thoughts offer very little to act on. An incorrect fact needs correcting, and an unanswered question may need clarification. The more I guess how someone will react, the more I overthink it.

There is a difference between reviewing work so I can learn from it and mentally revising something nobody has questioned. I would like to get better at recognising which one I am doing.

A reasonable place to stop

I don’t want to become careless, but ‘don’t think so much’ has never struck me as particularly useful advice.” What helps is deciding what I am checking before I begin another read. Have I answered the brief? Is the information accurate? Will the reader understand what they need to do?

Those questions give the review a purpose and a finishing point. If something still bothers me, asking a colleague a specific question usually helps more than another solitary round of edits.

I will probably continue to reread emails before sending them. But I want to get better at trusting the judgement that helped me write them in the first place. Being thoughtful is part of my job. Knowing when the work is ready to leave my hands is part of it too.

Know the Author

Share

Share your thoughts

Every perspective matters—we'd love to hear yours.

More related articles

The (Not So) Subtle Art of Overthinking at Work

As a writer, I can defend some of this attention. Choosing words carefully is part of my work. What becomes harder to defend is spending ten minutes choosing between two sentences that communicate exactly the

How to take Client Feedback: Step One, Yell at AI First

Just this week, I was asked to make a headline sound “more premium, but friendlier.” It was already friendly. I asked what premium meant in this context. The answer was, “You know. More elevated.” I

What Copywriting Has in Common With Love Letters

One is written for someone you love. The other is written for someone you hope will care. But neither can afford to be careless with words. Both ask you to look closely at another person,